<html><div style='background-color:'><P>It is all a matter of choice.................. If one's work is teaching, by all means there should be a charge for lessons. If one chooses to give lessons without charge then so be it. I studied with Ronnie for a number of years always felt that the price for the lesson was more than fair. Especially considering his rank and experience. One couldn't get that value for the price in any other musical venue. I'm also a singer and to get a lesson from a top teacher it is not unusual to pay $100.00 + for a lesson. And even at that price you won't get the return of value that you'd get from a lesson with Ronnie. </P>
<P>I've taught lessons both for pay and no pay. For me it was the circumstances surrounding them. I have another job where I earn a living. And my students were young people and prepairing for scholastic performances so I was glad to donate my time in instructions. If an adult wanted to study I'd probably charge a nominal rate. But I don't depend upon teachning to make my living. </P>
<P>Again it comes down to choice.</P>
<P><FONT face="Lucida Handwriting, Cursive" size=6><FONT size=3>Dale</FONT> <IMG height=12 src="http://graphics.hotmail.com/emwink.gif" width=12></FONT></P>>From: "NYOGETSU@NYC.RR.COM" <NYOGETSU@nyc.rr.com> >Reply-To: Shakuhachi@communication.ucsd.edu >To: Bruce Jones <Shakuhachi@communication.ucsd.edu> >Subject: Re: [Shaku] shakuhachi >Date: Fri, 11 Mar 2005 11:59:37 -0500 > >Dear Shakuhachi List, > >I have been following this thread for some time, and while my husband is >away in Mexico teaching I feel compelled to speak for him. > >Ronnie has worked very hard to be able to make his living from shakuhachi. >For that I am very proud of him. He has also inspired many of his students >in the last few years to do the same. > >To suggest that he should teach for free is ludicrous. How should we pay >our bills? Should he
get another full-time job, one that he doesn't like, >so that he can teach people like you for free? > >If you're complaining about his prices, but yet claim to really want to >study with him, then here's my suggestion: barter. Ronnie has students that >can't afford to pay, so they do work exchange with me on our land in upstate >NY. We can also barter for other things. So if you really want to study >with my husband there is a way, but if you want to get it for free or in an >exchange for your pretty smile it ain't gonna happen! > >Ronnie already does his own volunteer work at hospitals, for the elderly, >etc. > >What people may not know is that during the time of preparation for the NYC >Shakuhachi Festival Ronnie had a severe heart attack, whose effects are >still felt today. In spite of this, he persevered and helped to create a
>wonderful festival. > >I do not appreciate you talking about my husband's weight. You say you are >not trying to be "mean", but I think that you are. What place does this >type of commentary have on this list? You say you respect these teachers >but yet, couching it in terms of concern, you denigrate them. If you were >really concerned for my husband's health then you would contact him >personally and privately. That is the generous compassionate thing to do. > >Yours truly, > >Brenda Seldin >"Proud Wife of Shakuhachi Grand Master" > > > > > > > > > > I'm glad that I said what I said and got this > > discussion going. Because people have to know these > > things and they have to be acknowledged. If I feel a > > certain way, there is a reason for this.... > > > > I want to say Perry Yung is
awesome..... > > > > I want to say Ronnie Seldon is awesome at playing > > shakuhachi but I question alot about him.... I wish he > > would get on a excersice/diet plan because it would be > > nice to have him around awhile to play his > > shakuhachi.... I dont mean this in a mean way... I > > also wish that he didnt charge 60 dollars a lesson. > > Isnt there exceptions for poor people that have heart > > and soul and wanna learn real bad???? Ive had no > > teacher for 4 years and still play everyday and even > > make my own flutes and give them away....this is > > dedication.... I think I deserve a good teacher but > > if none show up then I will be a good teacher....... > > > > I wanna say if anyone is in Japan call this man he is > > awesome - more awesome than any other shakuhachi >
> player Ive heard of > > > > Hirobe, Chikutei > > 229 5-19-3 Hashimoto, > > Saganihara - shi, Kanagawa > > tel: 042-773-6113 > > > > He has played shakuhachi since he was 5 and he is now > > a retired tokyo university proffesor. He taught me > > shakuhachi for 2 months for free then I had to come > > back to NY State. I wanted to pay him but he said no > > - pay me with your dedication to the flute. He let me > > touch/play his 30,000 dollar flute. He plays live > > concerts with his 80 year old uncle. his 80 year old > > uncle is his teacher. > > > > Screw politics, screw money -heart and soul is all you > > have when you die people.......... > > > > > > > > __________________________________ > > Do you Yahoo!? > > Make Yahoo! your home page >
> http://www.yahoo.com/r/hs > > _____________________________________________ > > > > List subscription information is at: > > http://communication.ucsd.edu/shaku/listsub.html > >_____________________________________________ > >List subscription information is at: > http://communication.ucsd.edu/shaku/listsub.html </div></html>
_____________________________________________
List subscription information is at:
http://communication.ucsd.edu/shaku/listsub.html
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Fri Jan 06 2006 - 10:00:44 PST
