I'll add my personal experience. I have a shop in Seattle where I make
flutes and give shakuhachi lessons. Over the years I have been visited
by many "self taught" players. A few have come up with a way of playing
shakuhachi that is both original and slightly interesting to listen to.
Most, however, played out of tune, with no understanding of dynamics, or
the ability to play the full range of the instrument.
I think that the shakuhachi is especially difficult to learn without a
teacher. It's extremely difficult to learn with a teacher. It's not
like the electric guitar that can be heard and seen on a daily basis in
our culture.
I also don't think that developing traditional technique need hinder us
from having our own style. A player can, besides practicing traditional
pieces, spend part of each practice improvising and playing along with
the radio, etc. in other styles.
Also, there's the often wonderful relationship between a teacher and a
student, that is part of the learning experience.
And I agree with Riley. Why try to reinvent the wheel?
Peter
-- Cloud Hands Music http://www.cloudhandsmusic.com/peteross/ (206) 587-7262, Fax: (206) 364-2341
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Wed Jan 12 2000 - 13:23:58 PST